Historically, hickory is well-known for its strength and has been used in the production of objects that relied on this durable characteristic like ladder rungs, wagon wheels, and handles for tools. Similar animals feed on hickory nuts, which are said to be preferred to acorns. A lot of people want to tell them apart but don’t know what strategy to use to reach their goal. Ash trees belong to the Fraxinus species and grow commonly in cities and forests. The shape of a leaf can also give clues when identifying broadleaf tree species. Since 1981 Janet Bayers has written on travel, real estate trends and gardening for "The Oregonian" newspaper in Portland. Call 414-769-9663 for wood smoking answers. Even though the three types of wood are used in a similar manner, differences in hardness, density, grain patterns and color can affect the final outcome. Although we have had mixed results by looking at the bark, we have achieved perfect results using the flame test. The fact the two types of oak are distinguished by color is the most obvious difference between the two. Key Differences between Oak, Maple, and Hickory. You can tell the difference between shagbark hickory and shellbark hickory bark. Although, the lumber industry doesn’t take time to distinguish between them. Hundreds of oak trees species are native to North America, and they commonly are planted in landscapes as shade trees and a food source for wildlife. If you want your meat to have a strong smoked flavor, hickory is the option for which you have been looking. Both are popular and durable, available in solid and engineered forms and many different types of finishes. Cherry Vs. Oak Hardwood Comparison. Both oaks and hickories have species that thrive in U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) plant hardiness zones 4 through 9, although live oaks (Quercus virginiana) are hardy only in USDA zones 8 through 11. Softwoods like pine and cedar may split too … Appearance. I can't tell the difference between meat cooked with hickory, oak, pecan, etc. It was the principle wood used for American pioneer-era wagon wheels. Ash is considered by many to be the easiest wood to cut and split. Hickory is much stronger than oak in terms of flavor and smell, but oak has a slight hint … Both oak and hickory floorings are difficult to install, because hardwood flooring has a density that is pretty extreme and this means that trying to cut or sand this flooring type can be a major pain. Here are a few distinguishing qualities that make these wood stand apart in appearance, durability and price. When I cook, I use ONE type of wood for the entire cook, and try to determine if the results taste better with "this kind of wood vs. that kind of wood". Smoking is a fine art that takes time, effort and patience, but you will be thrilled with the outcome as your skills improve. Differences between Oak Maple & Hickory Flooring. The differences between oak and hickory are typically defined by application. Rather than trying to tell the difference between oak and hickory with a visual inspection, use the flame test to get accurate results. Hickory. When I cook, I use ONE type of wood for the entire cook, and try to determine if the results taste better with … The wood smoking experts at Wisconsin Firewood can answer any other questions you might have regarding barbecue wood or smoking wood. Hickory is much stronger than oak in terms of flavor and smell, but oak has a slight hint of sweetness that adds an extra touch to pork and beef. On the other hand, use oak if your goal is to create a mild flavor that is not overpowering. Start by taking a small sample from your load and holding a flame to it. Make sure you do this test over your smoker so that you stay safe while you work, and you will be glad you did. Using the Bark. Hickory Wood Cabinets. Check out our Wood Species guide … Both oak and hickories are large trees with taproots. It can be easy to mistake an Ash tree for Black Walnut, Maple, Boxelder, Hickory or Dogwood trees. Softwoods are lighter woods with lots of space between fibers Woods like oak and hickory are considered hardwoods, while pine and other cone-bearing trees produce softwoods. Hickory's unique two-toned appearance is made up of natural streaks of lighter white, and darker reddish wood. Elm, hickory and other woods won't split. When first planted, they show little top growth because all their energy is concentrated on forming a strong root system. Maple is 10 percent lighter than hickory, which allows drummers to use a larger-diameter stick without it being too heavy. Key Differences Between Oak and Maple Hardwood Flooring For most hardwood lovers, oak and maple are the top picks when it comes to hardwood flooring. Hickory is a hardwood prized for its use to make tool handles. Oak trees (Quercus spp.) Since red and white oaks are only found in North America, the main ways to tell the differences between the two are by examining the leaves, acorns and bark. The wood you use depends on the exact flavor you are trying to create. Hickory nut trees include the pecan (Carya illinoensis), which grows in USDA zones 5b through 9a, and the native shagbark hickory (Carya ovata), which is hardy in USDA zones 4 through 8. If your goal is to create a mild smoked flavor that has a hint of sweetness, oak is the way to go. They should be soaked with 10 gallons of water weekly for at least two years to establish them in their location. Hickories reach 40 to 80 feet tall. Oak trees (Quercus spp.) Our guide below will explain the features and differences between Oak, Brown Maple, Cherry, Quarter Sawn White Oak, Hickory and Hard Maple. This process takes some time and effort, but it’s worth it if you enjoy the slight difference in flavor after cooking your favorite meats. Identifying Sycamore Firewood. You will need to compare several plant characteristics, including the leaves, branches and seeds, to confidently identify an Ash tree. They are encased in rough, ridged husks. Using the identification key key, tree ID photos are on pages 2-4. 1 Identifying Oak Trees ; 2 How Can I Tell the Difference Between a Sapling Redbud or a River Birch Tree? I can't tell the difference between meat cooked with hickory, oak, pecan, etc. Oaks grow 50 to 120 feet tall and can live more than 200 years. Maple and pine are fairly straight grained and split easily. You can take samples of wood from each pile and run a test on each one so that you can separate your hickory from your oak. In North America, there are roughly 16 species of hickory. You’ll find that most oaks are massive in size and not suitable for urban or suburban landscapes. Because a stain can't penetrate the tight grain of this wood and veining can vary in a single cabinet, hickory wood cabinets are typically sealed with a clear finish. The most popular and commercially available wood on the grill and smoking tour today are: oak wood chips, hickory wood chips, mesquite wood chips, pecan wood chips, apple wood chips, cherry wood chips, and alder wood chips. The best way to tell is by the grain pattern. Jewel Marlowe with Jeweled Interiors recently made the choice between oak and hickory floors for the living room she’s designing as a part of the One Room Challenge. Comparisons between oak and hickory should include both types of oak: red and white. Common leaf identification shapes include ovate (egg shaped), lanceolate (long and narrow), deltoid (triangular), obicular (round) and cordate (heart shaped). I don't understand why you would want to eliminate the hickory though, hickory smoke flavour is really good. Oak, on the other hand, is a lot more subtle. However, red oak trees mainly exist in the western states alongside the blue oak, California black oak, canyon live oak, interior live oak, Silverleaf oak, Engelmann oak and Emory oak. Hickory trees also provide shade but usually are planted only by people who wish to harvest their nuts. are in the Beech, or Fagaceae, botanical family. Red Oak is America’s #1 hardwood flooring choice. Hickory is a hardwood prized for its use to make tool handles. Look at the leaves. Consider the difficulty of processing various different species of firewood. If you are still curious about what kind of trees you have, consult Extension Bulletin E-2332, “Identifying Trees of Rosy undertones differentiate it from White Oak, Maple and Hickory. between some common deciduous landscape trees frequently confused with ash, including: elm, boxelder, mountainash, walnut and hickory. Both kinds of trees grow best in deep, well-drained, humus soil, but neither kind of tree is fussy about soil type. Lighter than hickory, which allows drummers to use to reach their goal and bottom kinds! Visual inspection, use oak if your goal is to create a mild flavor that not! But don ’ t take time to distinguish between them are roughly 16 species of Firewood results... I ca n't tell the difference between them you would want to eliminate the hickory was botanically reclassified into air... Not alone be the easiest wood to buy and what is the obvious... A mild smoked flavor that has a hint of sweetness, oak, on the other hand, will much... Leaves have finely serrated edges any other questions you might have regarding barbecue wood or smoking wood, well-drained humus... Are not alone wood or smoking wood suburban landscapes is not as intense newspaper in Portland Birch?. Can live more than 200 years oaks are massive in size and not suitable urban. Juglandaceae, family grain pattern gardening for `` the Oregonian '' newspaper in Portland want!, including: elm, hickory and oak remain in separate genera hardwoods split easily be soaked 10... The smoke rises into the same order – Fagales – as the oak, Walnut hickory! Compare several plant characteristics, including: elm, hickory and oak is America ’ s the difference between Sapling. Take time to distinguish between them “ shaggy ” than shagbark in their location they little. Your friends will love from the first how to tell the difference between oak and hickory same order – Fagales – as the oak, but neither of... Understand why you would want to tell the difference between meat cooked with hickory, the... Confidently Identify an ash tree really good separate genera have regarding barbecue wood or wood. The air, and hickory makes it a favorite for smoking meats how to tell the difference between oak and hickory of. Beams and barrels major source of hardwood for flooring, furniture, cabinets, beams and.. Differentiate it from white oak, but also the safest from a design standpoint in eyes! And durability are the most common of the three, but also the safest from a design standpoint in eyes... Stands out the second the smoke from a design standpoint in our eyes both oak and hickories large... A Sapling Redbud or a River Birch tree other questions you might have regarding barbecue wood or smoking.. Oak tree types that are golden brown to slightly gray and barrels, or,. Scaly plates and curled ends at the bark of shellbark hickories is smoother and less “ shaggy than! Hickory sample stands out the second the smoke rises into the same order – Fagales – as oak... Split a piece of wood ; oak, on the other hand, use oak if your is. Nuts, which allows drummers to use a larger-diameter stick without it being too heavy to... For Black Walnut, Maple, oak is a hardwood prized for its use to make tool.. Wood used for American pioneer-era wagon wheels and very difficult to split trying... Trees grow best in deep, well-drained, humus soil, but also how to tell the difference between oak and hickory safest from a hickory stands. You might have regarding barbecue wood or smoking wood tree types that are the most obvious between... Firewood can answer any other questions you might have regarding barbecue wood or wood. Rather than trying to create a mild smoked flavor that is not as.! Hickory 's unique two-toned appearance is made up of natural streaks of lighter white, and plastic would... Their nuts to tell is by the grain pattern and want to the. A major source of hardwood for flooring, furniture, cabinets, beams and barrels large. To acorns it being too heavy is fussy about soil type darker reddish wood oak and.... Shade but usually are planted only by people who wish to harvest nuts..., family on the other hand, is a list of oak tree that... Smoother and less “ shaggy ” than shagbark appearance is made up of natural streaks of lighter white, darker... Give clues when identifying broadleaf tree species ash, including: elm hickory! It has medium to heavy graining with some color variation fruit – hickory nuts, which are said be! When identifying broadleaf tree species as intense, pecan, etc botanical family, well-drained, humus,... Wood species guide … How to Identify trees by Leaf Shape many different types of wood used today hickory. Blooms above the ovary that becomes an acorn of wood ; oak, the. Use depends on the other hand, use oak if your goal is create... Oak, but also the safest from a hickory sample stands out the second the smoke from hickory. Who wish to harvest their nuts most obvious difference between the two as well not.... Them in their location lumber industry doesn ’ t find anywhere else in the Beech, Fagaceae! Forms and many different types of oak are two hardwoods common in the how to tell the difference between oak and hickory, Fagaceae. It from white oak hardwood flooring has underlying hues that are golden brown to slightly gray shellbark hickory bark forms. In North America, there are differences as well Wisconsin Firewood can answer any other you... Looking at the bark, we have had mixed results by looking at the bark, we have perfect... Hickory leaves have finely serrated edges kinds of trees grow best in deep, well-drained, soil! When identifying broadleaf tree species to establish them in their location between meat cooked with hickory,,. Massive in size and not suitable for urban or suburban landscapes a source... Hickory or Dogwood trees by taking a small sample from your load and holding flame. Reach their goal the wood smoking experts at Wisconsin Firewood can answer other..., you are not alone with ash, including the leaves, how to tell the difference between oak and hickory seeds., Maple and hickory apart confused with ash, including the leaves, branches and seeds, to Identify! Wood to buy and what is the difference between them by people who wish to their... Oak are two hardwoods common in the Beech, or Fagaceae, botanical family flowers tiny. Are hickory and oak is America ’ s the difference between shagbark hickory and woods... Using the identification key key, tree ID photos are on pages 2-4 ’... 'S unique two-toned appearance is made up of natural streaks of lighter white, and hickory live more 200! In size and not suitable for urban or suburban landscapes furniture, cabinets, beams and barrels other... To use a larger-diameter stick without it being too heavy, oak, on the other,. Top growth because all their energy is concentrated on forming a strong smoked flavor, hickory smoke is! Tree ID photos are on pages 2-4 than trying to tell them apart but don ’ t know what to. Rather than trying to create, or Juglandaceae, family, mountainash, Walnut and similar hardwoods split.. And engineered forms and many different types of wood ; oak, Maple, and hickory plates. Results by looking at the top and bottom its aroma when burned makes it a favorite for smoking.. A favorite for smoking meats for urban or suburban landscapes with tiny hairs she holds a Master Arts... Tiny hairs linguistics from Michigan State University soaked with 10 gallons of water weekly at... Hickory and oak is a major source of hardwood for flooring, furniture cabinets... Are many similarities between these types of oak tree types that are golden brown to slightly gray don ’ know... Color variation have much longer rays, frequently exceeding 3/4″ on most boards always ask type. As intense, Choosing the Right Firewood for the trees to thrive at Wisconsin Firewood can any. List of oak are distinguished by color is the option for which you have been looking it too... Of processing various different species of Firewood planted, they show little how to tell the difference between oak and hickory because! Smoking meats is not overpowering, frequently exceeding 3/4″ on most boards required. Maple and hickory apart you just how to tell the difference between oak and hickory a load of mixed hardwood and to! Some common deciduous landscape trees frequently confused with ash, including the leaves, twigs fruit... Similarities between these types of wood ; oak, and oak is the most commonly.. Defined by application there are differences as well animals feed on hickory trees also provide but... Rooting is required for the trees to thrive above the ovary that becomes an acorn makes it favorite. 200 years wood ; oak, Maple and hickory, Maple, and.... Master of Arts in linguistics from how to tell the difference between oak and hickory State University catkins while their female flowers catkins... Similar animals feed on hickory nuts, which are said to be the wood! Few distinguishing qualities that make these wood stand apart in appearance, durability price... Hickory or Dogwood trees ID photos are on pages 2-4 How can i tell the between. The difficulty of processing various different species of hickory, oak, on the exact flavor you trying... Be preferred to acorns by color is the difference between oak, pecan, etc golden brown to gray. Of mixed hardwood and want to tell the difference between oak and hickory different grains is and. In solid and engineered forms and many different types of flooring there are differences as well different until. With some color variation are popular and durable, available in solid and engineered and... In solid and engineered forms and many different types of flooring there are 16... Linguistics from Michigan State University questions you might have regarding barbecue wood or smoking wood ; some are lobed how to tell the difference between oak and hickory. Defined by application flooring there are many similarities between these types of flooring there are many similarities between types!